Mise en Scène

A Fine Dining Journal

Back

Le Gabriel

"Two months after the promotion to three stars, the lineage behind it"

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Promotion

Section 1·

Paris is the home of fine dining the world over, and at the time of this writing, the city holds nine Michelin three-star restaurants. Le Gabriel is the most recent of them, elevated from two stars to three on 18 March 2024.

The news reached me on a weekday afternoon in mid-March 2024. I was at my desk in Seoul, scrolling Instagram, when the Michelin Guide France 2024 announcement appeared on my feed. One restaurant in Paris had moved from two stars to three: Le Gabriel. My European trip the following May had its final night in Paris, and that night happened to fall on a Monday. Finding a good Michelin restaurant in Paris that opens on a Monday is surprisingly hard, but Le Gabriel, fortunately, does. I booked immediately, securing a table that evening. By the following morning the calendar was full for months. It confirmed that the rush towards a newly promoted three-star is the same anywhere in the world.

Section 2·

Le Gabriel sits on the ground floor of La Réserve Paris, a Napoleon III mansion at the head of the Champs-Élysées near the Grand Palais.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Setting (1)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Setting (2)

The building was reworked by interior designer Jacques Garcia. Its owner is Michel Reybier, a name that will be familiar to anyone interested in wine: in addition to the hotel, he holds the Bordeaux second growth Cos d'Estournel and several other estates. That detail does not stay mere background; the wine list later in the evening shows why. The room held roughly nine tables, and its interior, laid thick with gilded leather and lacquer, felt like a room in a small palace.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Setting (3)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Setting (4)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Setting (5)

Only as I sat down did it sink in that I had arrived at the heart of a Paris three-star.

Section 3·

The chef here is Jérôme Banctel, and his career is a long one. Born in 1971 in Rennes, in Brittany, he entered hotel school at sixteen and began in 1991 in the kitchen of Michel Kéréver at the Duc d'Enghien, following him as far as the Netherlands. After military service, he passed through Le Jules Verne at the Eiffel Tower and then joined Les Ambassadeurs at the Hôtel de Crillon under Christian Constant. The defining stretch came next. He spent ten years as sous-chef at L'Ambroisie on the Place des Vosges, working under Bernard Pacaud, a period he has himself described as a rigorous school of classicism. In 2006, Alain Senderens brought him to Lucas Carton as executive chef. There he and Senderens reworked Senderens's signature dishes together, the Apicius duck among them, in work where two generations' views of cooking met, and in 2012 the two co-authored a cookbook. He joined La Réserve Paris when the hotel opened in 2015, secured two stars within a year, and reached the third in 2024.

Section 4·

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (1)

This lineage matters at the point of ordering. The tasting menu at Le Gabriel offers a choice between two parallel courses.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (2)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (3)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (4)

The first, Virée, traces Banctel's home region of Brittany and its produce. The second, Périple, compresses his career across the world, with explicit emphasis on Japan. The pricing is identical: 278 euros for seven courses, 378 euros for nine. What interested me was that, apart from the first dish, the two menus barely overlap. Even restaurants that run two menus usually share a good part of them, but here the house offers almost two separate dinners. Ordinarily I would have chosen the menu that compresses the chef's whole career and leans more towards his signature, which here meant Périple. But the description of Périple kept stressing Japanese touches and style, and that gave me pause. Few of the Asian touches I had met in European dining had left a lasting impression, and since Japan is only about two hours from Korea by plane, I also judged that its cooking is better eaten there. In Paris I wanted Paris. So I chose Virée, and ordered the full nine courses, judging that they would show more depth.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (5)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (6)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (7)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Menu (8)

The restaurant offered two pairing tracks. The standard, Their Best Discoveries, came at 192 or 232 euros depending on whether one ordered seven or nine courses. The elevated tier, Iconic Terroir and Grand Cru, was priced at 622 or 722 euros. I was on the final night of a longer trip and carrying the accumulated fatigue, and above all I had read in advance that Le Gabriel's by-the-glass list was excellent. I declined both pairings and intended to work through the meal by the glass.

In Paris I wanted Paris.

Section 5·

The welcome champagne was a Jeeper rosé, a house I had not encountered before. It was decent enough.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (1)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (2)

The amuse-bouche arrived in four pieces. Two of them stood out.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (3)

The first was an olive in a bright green sauce.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (4)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (5)

The second was an oyster, and the oyster surprised me. The oysters served at casual seafood restaurants in Europe are usually the long kind we see in Korea, and on their own they have seldom left much of an impression on me. There was one exception: a Galician oyster at a high-end seafood restaurant in Barcelona. Round in shape, deep in aroma, firm in texture. I had not expected an oyster of that same form to appear again among the amuse-bouches of a Paris three-star.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (6)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (7)

The sauce and jelly served with it made a good combination too. The piece topped with caviar was comparatively ordinary.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (8)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Opening (9)

Section 6·

Before the course proper began, the menu came to the table once more so the order could be confirmed. The first dish, Signature Vegetable in Limestone, was a pair of vegetable plates cooked in limewater, a technique the chef is said to have discovered in Turkey: one of carrot, one of beet. The carrot, which came first, was the standout.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (1)

Its texture, close to that of steamed garlic, had been achieved in an unusual way, and although I do not usually care much for carrot, a murmur of admiration escaped me at the first bite.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (2)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (3)

This one plate alone made the start of the evening's menu convincing.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (4)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (5)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (6)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (7)

Bread arrived before the second course in two forms, a soft loaf and a hard-crusted version.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (8)

Distinguishing among French Michelin breads is largely an unproductive exercise; the floor is high enough that the question rarely matters. What was noticeable here was the relatively modest amount of butter served. The sauces, though, were rich and deep, so the bread went down naturally as I used it to wipe the leftover sauce from each plate.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (9)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (10)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Vegetable (11)

Section 7·

The second course was «Gravlax» sardine, candied bell pepper, fried capers. Thinly cut sardine, treated as if it were sashimi, paired with herring roe, a fried-caper sauce, and slim ribbons of bell pepper. It was the best raw fish dish I had eaten in European fine dining. Above all, the freshness of the sardine itself came close to what I find in Japan, and the lively aroma and flavour of the sardine came through clearly. The portion was also substantial.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (1)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (2)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (3)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (4)

Raw fish dishes in European dining are often little more than a mouthful, so I sometimes feel I have missed the chance to eat them properly; this dish satisfied on that count as well.

The third was the abalone, with lentil salad beneath, caviar on top, and a thinly grilled seaweed crisp set alongside. The intent was visible, but this was the most disappointing course of the evening. Abalone's greatest strength is the tender texture of its flesh along the grain, but that tenderness was masked by the other textures and aromas on the plate and never fully came through. The principle that the more elements a plate has, the clearer its lead should become, did not quite work here.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (5)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (6)

I changed glass once across these courses. The first was a Cos d'Estournel Blanc 2017, a Bordeaux white in a vintage I had not previously tasted, arriving at a reasonable by-the-glass price.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (7)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (8)

The second white moved into Burgundy: Domaine Bruno Clair's Morey-Saint-Denis "En La Rue de Vergy" 2017, chosen with an eye on the lobster course to come.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (9)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (10)

The sommelier suggested the Bordeaux first on the basis that it would read fruitier and the Burgundy more butter-forward; we drank them in that order, but looking back, the reverse order might have suited the flow of the evening better.

The fourth course was the first of the two dishes unique to the nine-course menu: Binchotan grilled lobster, Corn Velvety, Sour Sorrel. Binchotan, the Japanese white charcoal, holds an edge in setting surface texture quickly while allowing even penetration of heat. The lobster on this plate was sizeable and the cooking precise enough that no obvious improvement suggested itself.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (11)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (12)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (13)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (14)

Spinach and corn sat below; a consommé arrived in a separate vessel alongside.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (15)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Sea (16)

From this point the flow of the menu grew interesting. The name Virée was meant to stress the colours of the chef's native Brittany, but put together the binchotan-grilled lobster, the use of consommé and the Japanese sense of the dish that would soon follow, and a Japanese shadow lay quietly across the whole menu. The two menus were said to be clearly separate, yet in practice the chef's Japanese sensibility was at work inside Virée too, at just the right intensity. This dish was the second-best course of the evening.

Section 8·

The fifth course was Mackerel on galet, confit amandine, bourride sauce. A trolley arrived bearing a tall silver steamer, and the server opened it at the table to reveal a presentation of distinctly Asian sensibility. A small performance of water mist accompanied the opening of the lid.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (1)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (2)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (3)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (4)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (5)

The cooking itself had been finished in the kitchen and only the display took place at the table, so it could not be called true guéridon service, but the staging up to the moment the plate arrived was well put together. The mackerel was cooked through to a yielding texture, and the bourride sauce was poured with appropriate balance.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (6)

The personal distance to mackerel as an ingredient, however, was harder to close. It is a fish I meet every day in Korea, and for someone used to its taste raw in particular, the novelty this plate could offer was limited. Skill aside, the impression it left was ordinary.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (7)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (8)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (9)

The sixth course, again exclusive to the nine-course menu, was Crispy pig's head «terrine», seaweed, cream and seashells. This was the best course of the evening. A garnish recalling the salinity of Korean fermented shellfish sat alongside, and at the centre sat the pig's head terrine, whose texture astonished me.

Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (10)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (11)
Le Gabriel, Paris: Steam and Smoke (12)

The terrine held its line while simultaneously carrying a near-fragile lightness; the salinity of the garnish and the soft cream added a different texture here and there. That the two courses unique to the nine-course menu, the binchotan lobster and this terrine, both occupied the high point of the evening was not coincidental. It gave me the impression that the menu had been deliberately built so that the heart of the nine courses stands apart from the middle of the seven. Should I return, the choice is clear, with no reason to hesitate. Nine courses.

It gave me the impression that the menu had been deliberately built so that the heart of the nine courses stands apart from the middle of the seven.

Section 9·

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Main (1)

The seventh and final main course was Hen farm chicken, buttermilk, white asparagus, wild garlic. Brittany is a region with a serious poultry tradition, and chicken in the main slot followed naturally from the Virée framing. Even so, I had the impression that the impact a chicken can make in the main slot of a Michelin menu has its limits.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Main (2)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Main (3)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Main (4)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Main (5)

The issue is not that the cooking falls short; it is that an ingredient encountered daily has a narrower range over which it can produce difference at this stage of a course. This was a slot that could have been taken into other corners of poultry, pigeon, wild quail or poularde, and with a farm chicken placed there, the last phrase of the menu did not quite close clearly.

As the main wound down, I returned to the wine list and pulled the Coravin section back open. Château Latour 2012 was on it, at 8cl for 120 euros. The price was far from light for one glass, but the fact that I had never tasted the wine won out in the end. The sommelier measured out exactly 8cl and, handing me the glass, added that I should drink it slowly, savouring the aroma to the very end. The aroma lingered in the mouth for a long time, and my companion, who had never heard the name Latour before, said it was clearly different in character from any wine we had met up to that day. I could take my time over the aroma of that one glass right through to the end of the meal.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Main (6)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Main (7)

Section 10·

Just before dessert came a small pre-dessert, bright with lime, to clean the palate.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (1)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (2)

The cheese course showed a way of handling cheese that made an impression on me.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (3)

Most French restaurants at this level arrive with a cheese trolley and a plated selection. Le Gabriel does not. The diner is offered a choice between two cheeses, Saint Nectaire AOP or Fourme d'Ambert AOP, and the selected cheese is then composed as a complete plate in the manner of a dessert course.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (4)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (5)

Saint Nectaire is the creamier side of the pair, less assertive on the nose; Fourme d'Ambert is denser, stronger, blue. It was a little disappointing not to be able to satisfy creamy and strong at once, but this time I chose creaminess over aroma and took the Saint Nectaire. It arrived under a heaped layer of thinly cut mushroom dusted with ground hazelnut. At the first bite, the flavour of the mushroom reached me before the cheese.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (6)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (7)

I learned there and then that cheese could also be turned into a single course of a meal in this way. Compared with the grammar of the classic French cheese course, carried by trolley and cellar alone, it was clearly more compressed and more editorial, and in terms of the flow of the meal it fitted rather well.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (8)

Dessert proper arrived in two plates. The first was a meringue piled with finely cut grapefruit; the second was built around strawberry.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (9)

The grapefruit plate, lively with acidity and freshness, struck the right balance for the close of the meal. The strawberry dessert leaned the other way: the sweetness pushed too far forward, and against the grapefruit plate the contrast was sharp.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (10)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (11)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (12)

On my two trips to France in 2024, in May and July, most of the desserts I met were built around fruit, and over those two trips the impression hardened that dessert is the course where French cooking brings out the season most clearly. In the same period, the desserts I met in Spain often chose creative variations, while the French tended to hold to the classical line. The petit fours arrived well past midnight, and my companion's fatigue was visible.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (13)
Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (14)

The plate was cleared in short order and we left. Alexandre Augé, who had shown us to our table, came out past the hotel entrance to see us off. He too looked visibly tired, as if the long hours standing with us through the end of the meal had caught up with him, but he held his posture to the last.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (15)

The wine programme at Le Gabriel deserves a paragraph of its own. Michel Reybier owns Cos d'Estournel among other estates, and that fact does not stay mere background: the restaurant keeps a separate, dedicated list of bottles from properties under common ownership, drawn from a depth of vintages. A neighbouring table was working through a Cos d'Estournel red on the evening of this visit. For anyone who takes wine seriously, the impression hardened that this is a good place to meet fine vintages from great Bordeaux houses on reasonable terms. Beyond the bottle list, the by-the-glass programme is split into two halves, standard pours and Coravin pours, with substantial depth on both sides. That depth is what naturally justified my decision to skip the pairings.

Considered as a whole, the Virée nine-course is at its strongest in seafood, with a Japanese sensibility laid here and there through the menu at just the right intensity. The weakest link was the chicken at the main, which left the impression that the menu did not close clearly. My companion found the food on the salty side overall. Even as someone used to salty food, I could agree, so clearly did salt run through the whole menu. Anyone who usually eats lightly seasoned food would do well to know this in advance. Beyond that, the service and the atmosphere of the room were clearly at three-star level, and eating a menu inside an interior like a small palace laid one more layer onto the impression of the whole meal.

That it had only just risen to three stars that year explains both the promise and the limits of the menu that night. The clear peaks of the two dishes in the middle of the meal, the binchotan lobster and the pig's head terrine, explain in themselves why this kitchen deserves its place at three stars. At the same time, the weakness in the menu's last phrase shows where a kitchen only just finding its feet at three stars still needs time. The meal made the choice for any return clear, with no reason to hesitate. Virée or Périple, and even if next time I move over to Périple, it will be nine courses.

Le Gabriel, Paris: The Close (16)